Dataset Viewer
Auto-converted to Parquet Duplicate
Domain
stringclasses
10 values
Task mode
stringlengths
4
24
Primary target
stringlengths
9
18
Better direction
stringclasses
2 values
Uniform
float64
0.35
75
Laya
stringlengths
2
5
Intern
float64
0
82.5
Llama
float64
0
81.8
Minitaur
float64
0
86.7
Qwen
float64
0
90
Nox
float64
0.18
99.3
CLM
float64
0
69.5
Jev
stringlengths
2
5
Opus
stringclasses
7 values
Sonnet
stringclasses
7 values
Haiku
stringlengths
3
6
Reference
float64
0
100
Evidence
Bayesian urn
Posterior MAE
lower
0.349
0.291
0.235
0.24
0.294
0.246
0.175
0.286
0.068
0.001
0.001
0.001
0
Evidence
Multiple-cue judgment
Human NLL
lower
2.197
2.342
1.57
2.687
1.984
3.012
1.491
2.675
+∞
n.a.
n.a.
n.a.
2.029
Evidence
Multi-attribute choice
Human NLL
lower
0.693
0.730
0.546
0.786
0.722
0.613
0.366
1.039
0.329
n.a.
n.a.
0.206s
0.192
Evidence
Probability coherence
Human MAE (pp)
lower
32.13
32.98
18.95
28.57
19.04
21.87
18.03
42.13
17.66
canc.
canc.
part.
16.54
Category
SHJ categories
Accuracy (%)
higher
50
50.0
65
52.9
54.5
71.3
94.5
50.4
87.4
n.e.
n.e.
91.2
93.8
Category
Medin categories
Accuracy (%)
higher
50
49.6
72.3
53.5
55.9
53.8
92.8
50.4
86.8
n.e.
n.e.
97.4
96.6
Category
Weather prediction
Accuracy (%)
higher
50
54.5
73
47.5
53.8
50.5
81.2
52.5
80.8
n.e.
n.e.
80.2
78.2
History
RLWM
Accuracy (%)
higher
33.3
34.9
77.8
41.7
49
59.3
86.3
36.7
89.5
n.e.
n.e.
89.4
89.3
History
Recent probes
Accuracy (%)
higher
50
49.7
82.1
55.6
49.5
53.5
99.3
55.9
99.0
n.e.
n.e.
100.0
100
Adaptation
WCST, prediction
Human NLL
lower
1.386
1.462
1.378
1.431
1.344
1.968
1.552
2.368
1.543
n.a.
n.a.
n.a.
0.84
Adaptation
WCST, autonomous
Accuracy (%)
higher
25
25.5
27.9
31.4
28.2
25.2
32.1
25.7
28.5
n.f.
n.f.
n.f.
48.9
Adaptation
Restless bandit
Better arm (%)
higher
50
55.4
65.6
57.1
49
50.5
69
52.6
63.9
part.
91.1
part.
68.8
Adaptation
Instrumental learning
Better arm (%)
higher
75
73.9
81.4
79.2
86.7
80
89.8
69.5
86.7
n.e.
n.e.
part.
94.9
Exploration
Horizon, prediction
Human NLL
lower
0.693
0.702
0.518
0.503
0.409
0.661
0.408
1.161
0.414
n.a.
n.a.
0.390s
0.4
Exploration
Horizon, autonomous
Optimal (%)
higher
50
54.8
78.7
66.4
71.7
63.3
86
50
82.9
n.f.
n.f.
n.f.
74.6
Exploration
Stationary bandits
Optimal arm (%)
higher
12.5
17.6
37.4
13.5
9.8
28.9
35.4
15.4
47.0
n.e.
n.e.
n.e.
68.1
Information
Hybrid sampling
Human NLL
lower
1.386
1.390
1.116
1.515
1.039
2.648
2.044
3.012
+∞
n.a.
n.a.
n.a.
0.264
Information
Mouselab, prediction
Human NLL
lower
1.634
1.717
2.109
2.743
2.125
2.464
1.619
7.817
1.458
n.a.
n.a.
n.a.
1.367
Information
Mouselab, autonomous
Expected return
higher
7.01
0.00
0
3.77
0
17.4
3.77
0
8.21
n.e.
n.e.
n.e.
11.77
Preference
BART
Mean reward
higher
0.84
0.00
0.74
0.28
0
0
4.72
1.03
1.76
n.e.
n.e.
6.27
10.49
Preference
Temporal discounting
Delayed reward (%)
null
50
0.0
16.7
0
80
90
16.7
0
50.0
n.e.
n.e.
77.8
41.5
Planning
Two-step
Mean reward
higher
0.5
0.50
0.52
0.5
0.51
0.52
0.53
0.49
0.55
n.e.
n.e.
0.55
0.52
Social
False-belief QA
Accuracy (%)
higher
50
39.5
82.5
81.8
65
82.8
81.9
67.4
71.5
n.e.
n.e.
82.6
100
Social
Politeness
Aggregate NLL
lower
1.014
1.192
0.799
1.584
1.008
1
0.749
1.195
+∞
n.a.
n.a.
+∞s
0.587
Social
Pragmatic interpretation
Aggregate NLL
lower
1.282
1.592
0.814
1.851
1.049
1.24
0.895
1.081
+∞
n.a.
n.a.
+∞s
0.416
Social
Nonliteral number
MAE to human mean
lower
34.77
30.86
16.87
25.1
28.53
29.75
17.73
18.97
20.37
15.34
20.81
22.52
4.98
Metacognition
Self-assessment
Human NLL
lower
2.039
+∞
2.029
2.523
1.885
2.262
1.893
3.094
+∞
n.a.
n.a.
n.a.
1.619

S1CogBench seven-model aggregate results

S1CogBench evaluates decision models on 24 cognitive tasks in 27 modes. It keeps human-response prediction, autonomous execution and event-probability reporting separate, using each task's original scoring with disclosed adaptations.

The current release contains the seven open models Laya, Intern-Decision-4B, Llama-3.1-8B-Instruct, Minitaur8B, Qwen3.5-4B, Decision-2.0-Nox-4B and CLM-v0.1-8B. It includes 189 primary scores and 70 shared-readout metric values for Horizon and WCST. These are the same accepted values published on GitHub, including the completed Nox and CLM sampling runs. No model was rerun for this synchronization.

Live leaderboard · GitHub · Current release details · Paper

Download the current results

from datasets import load_dataset

repo = "dengzhe-hou/S1CogBench"
revision = "seven-model-20261110"
table = load_dataset(repo, "main_table", revision=revision, split="train")
primary = load_dataset(repo, "primary_scores", revision=revision, split="train")
readouts = load_dataset(repo, "readout_controls", revision=revision, split="train")
rows = load_dataset(repo, "results", revision=revision, split="train")

The train split is a distribution label for aggregate evaluation results. It is not model-training data or a participant split.

Configuration Contents
main_table 27 task-mode rows with seven open-model columns, Uniform, task-specific references and the original API coverage. Printed values and footnote marks remain text.
primary_scores 189 unrounded primary scores, one per open model and task mode.
readout_controls 70 unrounded values from legal argmax and legal sampling across all seven models on Horizon and WCST. Horizon has two metrics and WCST has three.
results 2,085 aggregate records containing current primary scores and readout controls alongside retained historical diagnostics. Not every historical diagnostic covers all seven models.
rlwm_curves, bandit_condition_scores, api_time_cost Unchanged historical secondary tables with their original model and API coverage. These configurations do not imply seven-model curve or API coverage.

aggregate/primary_sources.json and aggregate/readout_sources.json retain provenance and the original scoring contexts. aggregate/table2.json links each printed cell to its result row. RELEASE.json records this release and the matching GitHub commit. Other retained reference, task, schema, status and validation files describe the original public snapshot and its coverage.

There is no pooled cognitive score or overall ranking. Compare matching task, protocol, mode, metric, target, unit and aggregation. Unrounded values are in the result records. Percentage fractions and printed percentage points have explicit units. Infinite and undefined values are retained without clipping or invented scores.

The readout runs retain the original task seeds, probability extraction and action-dependent feedback histories. CLM uses its original first-2048-token context. Nox's original native/argmax records used A100 MIG, whereas its added sampling runs used a whole A100. These scores do not establish a matched-hardware latency comparison. See the linked release details for checkpoint revisions and model-specific settings.

Reproduce or submit a result

Task runners, model-adapter templates, data acquisition and original scorers live on GitHub. Follow the quickstart and the model integration guide. To add an evaluated model to the public leaderboard, follow the submission guide. Reviewed aggregate submissions update the leaderboard after their GitHub pull request is merged.

This dataset contains aggregate results, not model weights or raw participant transcripts. Gated and third-party task inputs must be obtained from their original sources under their original terms.

Historical snapshot

The previous five-model dataset is preserved unchanged at the tag arxiv-five-model-20261103. Pass that tag as revision to access its original tables and dataset card. The current seven-model release is tagged seven-model-20261110.

License

The aggregate results are released under CC BY 4.0. Reference values computed from third-party human data keep the terms of their original sources, which aggregate/tasks.json lists for each task. The S1CogBench code on GitHub is MIT licensed.

Citation

@misc{hou2026s1cogbench,
  title         = {{S1CogBench}: What System One Decision Models Can and Cannot Do on Cognitive Experiments},
  author        = {Hou, Dengzhe and Yamada, Kazunori D},
  year          = {2026},
  eprint        = {2611.00911},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  primaryClass  = {cs.CL},
  url           = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2611.00911}
}
Downloads last month
242

Paper for dengzhe-hou/S1CogBench